Log In
Oh Dear
Capterra
4.9 (70)
G2
4.7 (31)

How is Oh Dear different from Icinga?

Icinga is a modern, Nagios-compatible open-source monitor. Oh Dear takes a wider view: uptime plus SSL, DNS, full-site crawling, cron checks and Lighthouse, in one tool with one bill. Here's the honest comparison.

Start monitoring

10 day free trial
No credit card required

Oh Dear vs Icinga
  • Bitmovin
  • HBO Nordic
  • Obsidian
  • Laravel
  • Fathom Analytics
  • PHP 8
  • Stanford University
  • Takeaway.com
  • IGN
  • VRT NWS
  • spatie
the quick verdict
Choose Oh Dear if you want uptime, SSL/TLS, DNS, full-site crawling, cron checks and Lighthouse in one place, with unlimited users and one predictable bill.
Choose Icinga if you like the Nagios plugin ecosystem but want a more modern core and web UI, and can self-host it.

What we have that Icinga doesn't

Hosted, zero maintenance

1. Hosted, zero maintenance

We run the servers, upgrades, probes and global checking locations. There is nothing to install, patch or babysit.

All-in-one, nothing to bolt on

2. All-in-one, nothing to bolt on

Uptime, SSL, DNS, full-site crawling, Lighthouse, cron and more are built in. No plugins, exporters or extra tools to assemble.

AI checks, crawl & Lighthouse

3. AI checks, crawl & Lighthouse

Natural-language AI checks, whole-site broken-link and mixed-content crawling, and real Lighthouse audits, none of which self-hosted monitors offer.

Oh Dear compared with Icinga

Oh Dear Icinga
Uptime monitoring? Yes Yes
Ping monitoring? Yes Yes
TCP port monitoring? Yes Yes
Performance monitoring? Yes Partial
Lighthouse audits? Yes No
Certificate health (SSL/TLS)? Yes Yes
Broken links & mixed content? Yes No
Sitemap monitoring? Yes No
DNS monitoring? Yes Yes
DNS blocklist monitoring? Yes Partial
Domain expiry monitoring? Yes Partial
Scheduled-task / cron? Yes Partial
Application health checks? Yes Partial
Port scanning? Yes Partial
AI-powered checks? Yes No
Notifications & integrations? Yes Partial
Status pages? Yes No
Single sign-on (SSO)? Yes Partial
Hosted & managed for you? Yes No
Zero setup & maintenance? Yes No
All-in-one, nothing to bolt on? Yes No
Entry price? €15 Free

Sourced from each vendor's docs · June 2026

Try 10 days for free
When Icinga is the better call

Modern Nagios-compatible core

Best if you want Nagios plugin compatibility with a more modern engine and web interface, and have the team to run it.

Weighing other tools?

See how Oh Dear compares across the board, or head-to-head against another monitor.

All comparisons vs Uptime Kuma vs Zabbix vs Nagios vs Prometheus vs Checkmk

Frequently asked questions

Target rings Target rings

Icinga is a good choice if you want open-source software you fully control and self-host, and you have the time and ops skills to install, configure, secure and maintain it. Choose it when control and zero licensing cost outweigh the setup and upkeep.

Oh Dear is fully hosted with nothing to run or maintain, and includes website-specific checks self-hosted tools lack out of the box: AI-powered checks, full-site broken-link and mixed-content crawling, sitemap monitoring, real Lighthouse audits and public status pages, all in one place.

The software is free, but you pay in servers, setup, upgrades, security patching and the engineering time to keep it running, plus the risk that your monitoring goes down together with your own infrastructure. Oh Dear runs independently of your stack from €10/month.
See all other FAQ items →

Start monitoring instantly

Start a no-strings-attached 10-day free trial. You're all set in less than a minute.
(No credit card needed.)

Not convinced yet? Need help?
Get in touch via [email protected].